Top 10 Most Underrated Premier League Players Of All Time

You might think you know everything about the Premier League, but those players always seem to slip under the radar.

Some of these unsung heroes have played vital roles in their teams’ successes yet never quite received the recognition they deserved.

We’re here to shine a light on those underrated talents who have graced English football’s top flight over the years and prove. That sometimes it’s not just about goals and flashy skills; it’s also about hard work, determination, and unrelenting commitment.

In this retrospective, we’ll be looking back at the Premier League Players history. Of the Premier League and highlighting the top 10 most underappreciated players in the league’s history.

You’ll discover some familiar faces for various reasons – be it injuries or playing in less glamorous positions – and others who didn’t get their due credit for consistently excellent performances.

So please sit back, relax, and allow yourself to escape into the world of soccer appreciation as we pay homage. To these unsung heroes whose dedication has made them genuinely deserve more recognition.

1. James Milner

Premier League Players

You’ve probably overlooked James Milner’s versatility and consistency throughout his Premier League career. But that makes him one of the most underrated players ever.

Milner has played in various positions for multiple clubs, including Leeds United, Newcastle United, Aston Villa, Manchester City, and Liverpool.

As a player who can excel on both wings, central midfield, or even as a full-back when required, he embodies the spirit of adaptability and tireless work ethic. That every manager dreams of having in their squad.

Milner’s relentless drive to succeed on the pitch is infectious; you can’t help but admire his never-say-die attitude and commitment to the cause.

He may not possess the flair or showmanship of other top Premier League stars like. Thierry Henry or Cristiano Ronaldo, but make no mistake – his impact is just as significant.

With multiple league titles under his belt, domestic cups. Premier League Players and European triumphs such as Champions League success with Liverpool in 2019. It’s time to give this unsung hero the recognition he deserves.

So take a moment to appreciate James Milner – a true embodiment of freedom through hard work and dedication on the football pitch. Which has made him an indispensable asset for any team he’s been part of.

Related: Top 10 Greatest Stoke City Players Of All Time

2. Leighton Baines

Premier League Players

Leighton Baines, often flying under the radar, has consistently proven himself as a solid left-back with an incredible ability to take free kicks and penalties.

His career spanned over 15 years at Wigan Athletic and Everton. Showcasing his talent for providing accurate crosses, ensuring defensive stability, and contributing valuable goals from set pieces.

While he may not have received the recognition he deserved on a national level, his club performances were nothing short of exceptional.

Baines boasts a remarkable record of converting penalties. With an impressive success rate of 88%, putting him among the best penalty-takers in Premier League history.

Throughout his time at Everton, Baines provided a whopping 53 assists. Making him one of the top assisting defenders in England’s top flight.

Despite being a defender by trade, Leighton scored 32 Premier League goals. Primarily through his deadly free kicks that struck fear into opposing goalkeepers.

By appreciating these stats and accomplishments achieved by Leighton Baines throughout his career. One can’t help but feel inspired by this underrated gem of English football.

His commitment to excellence motivates those who Premier League Players strive to break. Free from limitations imposed upon them by society or their self-doubt.

Embrace Baines’ example; let it be your guiding light toward realizing your dreams . Proving that you can achieve greatness even if you’re flying under the radar!

3. Mark Noble

Premier League Players

Mark Noble might not be a household name, but his consistent performances and leadership qualities have undoubtedly impacted the pitch.

As West Ham United’s captain and longest-serving player, Noble has been a critical figure in the heart of their midfield for over 15 years.

His tireless work rate, accurate passing, and ability to read the game have often gone under the radar, but those who watch him closely know just how valuable he is to his team.

Noble’s underrated status to several factors: playing for a mid-table club like West Ham rather than one of the Premier League giants; being overshadowed by flashier teammates.

And perhaps most significantly, never earning an England cap despite his consistently high level of play.

However, when you look at some of his career statistics compared to other English midfielders who have received more recognition, it becomes clear that Noble deserves more credit:

Statistic Mark Noble Comparable Midfielder
Appearances 400+ 300-500
Goals 60 40-80
Assists 60 30-70
Pass Completion % 85% 80%-90%

These numbers show that Mark Noble has been a reliable performer throughout his career, contributing offensively and defensively while maintaining impressive consistency.

So next time you’re watching a West Ham match or discussing underrated Premier League players with your friends, remember to give Mark Noble the recognition he deserves.

Because even though he may not be as flashy or well-known as others in his position, there’s no denying that he’s been one of the league’s most dependable performers for well over a decade.

Related: Top 7 Best Youth Soccer Leagues In Massachusetts

4. Gareth Barry

Premier League Players

If all of you think Mark overlooked, let me introduce you to Gareth Barry – the man who’s played more Premier League games than anyone else but still won’t get invited to the cool kids’ table.

You might think, ‘How can someone with that many appearances be underrated?’ That’s just it; despite his impressive record of 653 Premier League appearances and a career spanning over 20 years, Barry has never received the credit he deserves.

This unassuming midfield maestro always made a solid shift for Aston Villa, Manchester City, Everton, and West Bromwich Albion without hogging the limelight or seeking personal glory.

Now let’s dive into what made Barry an incredible player on the pitch. With exceptional positional awareness and a high football IQ, he broke up plays and distributed the ball effectively while providing defensive cover for his teammates.

His versatility allowed him to play various roles in midfield and even fill in as a left-back when needed. Although not known for flashy skills or scoring goals (though he did bag 53 during his career).

His consistency and reliability game after game earned him respect from managers like Roberto Mancini and Tony Pulis.

So next time you’re reminiscing about Premier League greats or discussing underappreciated talents with your friends at the pub, don’t forget to raise a glass in honor of Gareth Barry.

One of the unsung heroes of English football who quietly etched his name into history through sheer grit, determination, and love for the beautiful game.

5. Claude Makélélé

Premier League Players

Now, let’s talk about Claude Makélélé – a man whose influence on the game was so immense that they named a position after him! Having played for clubs like Real Madrid, Chelsea, and Paris Saint-Germain during his illustrious career, Makélélé was an unsung hero.

The Frenchman’s tactical awareness and unparalleled defensive skills in midfield allowed his teammates to express themselves freely on the pitch.

These five key attributes can best describe Makélélé’s playing style:

  • Unselfishness: Always putting the needs of the team before personal glory
  • Tenacity: Never giving up on challenges or loose balls
  • Tactical intelligence: Understanding how to break down opposition tactics and create space for his teammates
  • Leadership: Commanding respect from both teammates and opponents alike
  • Consistency: Delivering top-notch performances week in, week out

These qualities made him one of the most underrated yet essential cogs in any team he played for.

If you’re striving for freedom, consider taking a page out of Makélélé’s book – selflessly support those around you while never losing sight of your goals.

You might discover that by doing so, you will achieve success and leave a lasting impact, just like Claude Makélélé did on the beautiful game.

6. Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink

Premier League Players

Imagine witnessing the sheer power and accuracy of Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink’s thunderous strikes as he etched his name into football history with every goal he scored.

The Dutch forward, who graced the Premier League with his presence from 1997 to 2006, was a force during his time at Leeds United, Chelsea, Middlesbrough, and Charlton Athletic.

Despite being one of the most prolific goal-scorers in English football during that period, Hasselbaink remains an underrated gem in the annals of Premier League history.

As you reminisce about Hasselbaink’s incredible career, consider these impressive statistics:

Season Club Goals
1997-98 Leeds United 16
1998-99 Leeds United 18
2000-01 Chelsea 23
2001-02 Chelsea 29
2004-05 Middlesbrough 13

These numbers showcase just how lethal Hasselbaink was in front of the goal. His powerful shots and clinical finishing made him a nightmare for opposing defenders and goalkeepers.

Yet somehow, despite consistently delivering top-notch performances on the pitch, Hasselbaink never quite received the recognition he deserved.

It’s time for us to break free from our preconceived notions about what makes a player great and give this unsung hero of the Premier League the credit he is due.

7. Michael Carrick

Premier League Players

Can’t we all appreciate the sheer elegance and composure displayed by Michael Carrick throughout his illustrious career? Often overshadowed by flashier midfielders, Carrick quietly became one of the Premier League’s most reliable and consistent performers.

His ability to control the tempo of a game, break up opposition attacks with well-timed interceptions, and dictate play from deep positions was vital for both Tottenham Hotspur and Manchester United. Despite winning numerous trophies at Old Trafford, including five Premier League titles, Carrick somehow remained criminally underrated.

One aspect of Carrick’s game that often went unnoticed was his incredible vision. He had an uncanny ability to pick out inch-perfect passes over long distances or thread through balls between defenders with pinpoint accuracy.

This skill allowed him to create chances for his more attacking teammates while also being a key cog in maintaining possession for his team.

Moreover, he possessed an unwavering calmness under pressure – even when opponents were breathing down his neck; it seemed as if nothing could faze him.

No wonder Sir Alex Ferguson once referred to him as ‘the best English player in the game’!

So next time you watch a soccer match or discuss its unsung heroes with friends, remember Michael Carrick’s understated brilliance that contributed immensely to some truly memorable moments.

8. Kolo Toure

Premier League Players

You’ve got to admit Kolo Toure’s tenacity and determination on the field made him an invaluable asset for Arsenal, Manchester City, and Liverpool throughout his career.

His ability to adapt to different positions and systems allowed him to fit seamlessly into each team, providing a solid defensive presence that often went unnoticed by casual viewers.

Despite never being considered among the league’s top defenders, his dogged work ethic and commitment endeared him to fans who appreciated what he brought to their club.

Despite winning two Premier League titles with Arsenal and Manchester City respectively, Toure never quite received the recognition he deserved.

Often overshadowed by big-name teammates or more flashy players in attack-minded positions, Kolo was content to shut down opposition attacks quietly.

But true soccer specialists know just how crucial this underrated gem was during his time in the English top flight.

Club Appearances Premier League Titles
Arsenal 225 1
Man City 82 1
Liverpool 46 0

The table above highlights Kolo Toure’s importance as a consistent performer for some of England’s biggest clubs during their title-winning seasons.

With nearly 350 appearances in the Premier League alone, it’s clear that managers trusted him as a critical component of their squads, yet he discusses the league’s greatest defenders.

As you continue exploring the world of soccer, remember those unsung heroes like Kolo Toure who fought tirelessly behind the scenes.

Embodying that spirit of freedom we all crave on some level – and appreciate them for their significant contributions, which may have gone unrecognized but were genuinely indispensable.

Related: Top 7 Best Youth Soccer Leagues In Colorado

9. Darren Anderton

Premier League Players

Reflecting on Darren Anderton’s career, it’s evident that his remarkable skill and versatility in midfield positions truly set him apart from many of his contemporaries.

His ability to play as a winger, central midfielder, or deep-lying playmaker allowed him to adapt to different systems and tactics quickly.

Anderton was a hard worker with a reputation for precision crossing and long-range shooting despite a career marred by injury. He was often the driving force behind Tottenham Hotspur’s attacking plays during the 90s.

Anderton’s underrated status is perhaps due to playing in an era when the Premier League boasted numerous world-class talents like David Beckham, Paul Scholes, and Ryan Giggs – players who often stole the limelight.

Yet those who watched him closely would argue that he possessed just as much talent and impact on matches as these household names.

With more than 300 appearances for Spurs and 30 England caps under his belt despite battling injuries constantly, it’s clear that Anderton should be remembered not only for overcoming obstacles but also for showcasing an unwavering commitment to the beautiful game – something we can all admire.

10. Shay Given

Premier League Players

Shay Given had an impressive career spanning over two decades, and he’s undoubtedly one of the finest goalkeepers to have graced the football pitch.

With 451 appearances for Newcastle United alone and over 600 career club matches it’s no wonder he became a fan favorite for his agility, shot-stopping skills, and commanding presence between the sticks.

Despite his outstanding performances throughout his career, Given remains an underrated gem in Premier League history. Here are four key reasons why Shay Given deserves more recognition:

  1. Consistency: Throughout his time at Newcastle United and later stints with Manchester City, Aston Villa, Stoke City, and even a brief spell at Middlesbrough, Given maintained a high level of performance that few goalkeepers could match.
  2. Leadership: As Ireland’s most capped goalkeeper with 134 international appearances, Given was known for his ability to marshal defenders effectively and instill confidence in those around him.
  3. Adaptability: While many players struggle when moving from one club to another or adjusting to new managers’ playing styles, Given consistently proved himself adaptable by thriving under various coaching setups.
  4. Big game player: Shay Given had an uncanny knack for producing match-winning saves in crucial moments, making him stand out among other goalkeepers.

Despite these remarkable qualities, Shay Given still doesn’t get the credit he deserves as one of the Premier League’s all-time greats.

Perhaps it’s due to playing during an era when other iconic goalkeepers like Peter Schmeichel or Edwin van der Sar grabbed headlines; nevertheless, you shouldn’t overlook this extraordinary talent who gave fans unforgettable memories filled with stunning saves and unwavering passion for soccer!


You’ve witnessed the unsung heroes, the hidden gems of the Premier League throughout its history. It’s time they bask in the limelight and receive their due appreciation.

So next time you’re reminiscing about soccer legends, tip your hat off to these underrated maestros. Their impact on the game may have been subtle, but it was undeniably effective, like a well-timed through ball.

Manuel Esposito

Hello everyone! My name is Manuel and I've recently got my PhD in Sport and Excercise Science at the University of Portsmouth. I'm raised and born in New York, and I've been a big fan of soccer my whole life. Soccer is the reason why I got my PhD in Sport and Excercise Science, and my goal with this blog is to help you improve your soccer techniques, strategies, and knowledge!

Press ESC to close